A Comparision of Serious Brushcutters

 

Who is this aimed at?

People with large rural blocks who want advice on the pros and cons of 2 stroke and 4 stroke brushcutters and their attachments.

Who is writing it?

I own 56Ha or 140acres of very fertile, wet land in the high rainfall belt of sub-topical south east Queensland in Australia. I grow trees. My property has a large number of weeds including woody weeds and tall rank pastures.

 

 

 

Safety Warning

These are powerful machines and you should always read the manual in full before using them. Follow all instructions and wear safety gear.

I will not cut without:

  • Sturdy boots (steel capped if using a chainsaw head)
  • Thick leg coverings such as jeans or overalls (chainsaw chaps if using a chainsaw head)
  • Safety glasses
  • Helmet with a visor and earmuffs or at least a hat and earmuffs

If you don’t think you need to wear this type of safety gear, you don’t need a machine like these.

 Demonstration of safety gear

2 Stroke vs 4 Stroke?

I have both. My 2 stroke is a Stihl FS450. The 4 Stroke is a Honda U425. In laymans terms the Stihl is a beast and the Honda is a medium machine. They each have their pros and cons. I’ve also used the Husqvana 325Rx 2 stroke machine which feels the lightest and more powerful than the Honda. Lets start with what they have in common.

Common Points 

Serious brushcutters : 

  • have straight shafts and bicycle handlebars.  Anything less is not a serious machine.
  • have comfortable harness (See photo)
  • take enough fuel to last for more than an hour of hard work.
  • are designed for use with a blade.

Specs of models I’m comparing.

It’s all about power and weight. These are all metric figures taken from the manufacturers website and are dry weights without cutting heads.

 

Basic Power to Weight comparison

 

Model

Power

Dry Weight

Stihl FS450

2.1 Kw

8kg

Honda UMK425 U4U

0.8Kw

6kg

Husqvarna 325Rx

0.9 Kw

4.8kg


Serious brushcutters side by side

 Main Differences 

2 Stroke

  • More powerful for same weight
  • Lighter for same power
  • Smelly
  • Noisy
  • More expensive to buy and run
  • You have to mix the fuel and if you get it wrong, you break the machine.

 

4 Stroke

  • Less power for same weight
  • Usually smaller and less powerful than the biggest two strokes
  • Cheaper to buy and run
  • Much quieter in idle. Probably more pleasant for observers to listen to
Close up of motors

 

 


Heads 

There are 3 basic types each with some variations.

Cord or Line Heads

Automatic or bump feed (photo)

Pro:
  • Easy to add release more line as it wears out
  • Best around things that a blade would damage e.g. paths, poles, caravans
  • Best when it’s very rocky or stony ground
Con:
  • Can’t use very thick line so you’re limited to ‘cosmetic’ work.

Manual feed (photo)

Pro:

Allows thicker cord that can get closer to matching it with a blade

Con:
  • It takes longer to replace than a bump feed
  • You have to replace the whole lot at once
  • You may have to take the brushcutter off and put it down to make the change
  • You may have to remove your gloves

Blades

 

Showing all cutting head types

3 Blade (photo)

Pro:
  • Best all round serious option – can handle anything
Cons:
  • Expensive
  • Heavy so you need a bigger machine
  • Requires sharpening on an angle grinder to make the best use
3 blade head

4 Blade Grass (photo)

Pro:
  • Absolute wiz at tall rank grass and woody weeds thinner than a finger.
  • Cheaper
  • Lighter
  • Easier to sharpen
Cons:
  • No good if it’s thicker than your thumb
4 pronged head - Grass Blade
 

Chainsaw Head (photo)

 Pro:
  • Best at woody weeds
  • Perfect for thickets of lantana
Con:
  • Expensive
  • Dangerous
  • Less control for direction of fall than a chainsaw
 
 

Weed Whacker (photo)

 Pro:
  • OK at most things
  • Saves your clutch
Con:
  • Expensive
  • Still clogs
  • Not for really tough going
 

 

What do I recommend?

Brushchutter?
  • The biggest, most powerful machine you can carry or that you are sure will get the job done (my view – I am 100kg and 187cm and attack the big ‘clearing’ jobs)
  • The smallest, least powerful machine you need to do the job you have to (my wife’s view – 50kg, 162cm and she does the repeat ‘maintenance’ jobs)
  • Too big is better than too small.
  • Any of these machines is great.
Head?

Get them all. They’re cheap. Use the one that best suits the job.

 

Brand / Store:

I will only buy from

  • a store that also services the things they sell
  • a specialist shop that can get you accessories and advise on the right one for the job
  • stocks more than one top shelf brand

 

 

Brushchutter?
  • The biggest, most powerful machine you can carry or that you are sure will get the job done.
  • Too big is better than too small.
  • Any of these machines is great.
Head?

Get them all. They’re cheap. Use the one that best suits the job.

 

Brand / Store:

I will only buy from

  • a store that also services the things they sell
  • a specialist shop that can get you accessories and advise on the right one for the job
  • stocks more than one top shelf brand